河北医科大学学报 ›› 2025, Vol. 46 ›› Issue (8): 906-915.doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1007-3205.2025.08.007

• • 上一篇    下一篇

辅助固定系统治疗内侧开放胫骨高位截骨TakeuchiⅡ型合页骨折的有限元研究

  

  1. 1.航空总医院骨关节科,北京 朝阳 100012;2.厦门医疗器械研发检测中心,福建 厦门 361000;
    3.河北医科大学第一医院骨科,河北 石家庄 050031

  • 出版日期:2025-08-25 发布日期:2025-08-29
  • 作者简介:李兵(1974-),男,辽宁调兵山人,航空总医院副主任医师,医学硕士,从事骨科疾病诊治研究。

  • 基金资助:
    河北省政府资助临床医学优秀人才培养项目(ZF2024132)

Finite element study on the treatment of Takeuchi type Ⅱ hinge fractures after medial open wedge high tibial osteotomy by auxiliary fixation system

  1. 1.Department of Orthopedics, Aviation General Hospital, Beijing 100012, China; 2.Xiamen Medical Device 
    Research and Testing Center, Xiamen 361000, China; 3.Department of Orthopedic Surgery, 
    the First Hospital of Hebei Medical University, Shijiazhuang 050031, China

  • Online:2025-08-25 Published:2025-08-29

摘要: 目的 内侧开放胫骨高位截骨(medial open wedge high tibial osteotomy,MOWHTO)TakeuchiⅡ型合页骨折后截骨端力学稳定性显著下降,可能影响预后,研究在原有内固定基础上加用辅助固定系统(auxiliary fixation system,AFS),对截骨端力学稳定性的影响,为Ⅱ型合页骨折的治疗及康复提供参考。
方法 采用CT扫描的人体下肢骨骼数据和TomoFix钢板、螺钉建立完整合页和TakeuchiⅡ合页骨折的MOWHTO有限元模型A、B,在模型B基础上加用AFS构建模型C。分别在模型胫骨平台上方加载不同轴向压缩载荷,模拟由坐到起立、行走状态,另外加载扭转载荷,模拟扭转状态。分别测量不同状态下内固定物最大应力和内侧截骨端和外侧合页部位最大移位量,以判断截骨端力学稳定性的变化情况。
结果 由坐到起立状态下,相较模型A,模型B、C钢板最大应力分别增加了178.3%、95.9%;内侧截骨端最大移位量分别增加了33.2%、29.7%;外侧合页部位最大移位量分别增加了51.0%、43.7%。行走状态下钢板最大应力分别增加了113.1%、91.9%;内侧截骨端最大移位量分别增加了17.2%、13.8%;外侧合页部位最大移位量分别增加了389.4%、385.1%。扭转载荷下钢板最大应力分别增加了261.4%、122.0%;内侧截骨端最大移位量分别增加了362.6%、242.1%;外侧合页部位最大移位量分别增加了338.8%、204.7%。相较于模型A,模型B、C在各种状态下钢板的最大应力均有增加,其中模型B增幅更为明显;相较由坐到起和行走状态,在扭转载荷状态下,模型B、C间的钢板最大应力增幅的差异最大,达到139.4%。
结论 Ⅱ型合页骨折会导致MOWHTO截骨端稳定性下降,特别是在由坐到起立和扭转状态下,术中需要加强合页周围的稳定性,术后在保护条件下做相应动作;加用AFS可以提高截骨端稳定性,分散内固定物的应力,理论上可减少内固定物失效、术后力线丢失、截骨端不愈合的发生率,相较单纯原有内固定可以更早部分负重,有利于快速康复,减少并发症,可考虑用于合页骨折的治疗,但仍需进一步的生物力学研究来证实。


关键词: 胫骨, 膝关节, 截骨, 有限元

Abstract: Objective The mechanical stability of the osteotomy site significantly decreases in patients with Takeuchi type Ⅱ hinge fractures after medial open wedge high tibial osteotomy (MOWHTO), which may affect prognosis. The purpose of this study is to explore the effect of auxiliary fixation system (AFS) supplemented on the basis of the original internal fixation on the mechanical stability of the osteotomy site, and to provide a reference for the treatment and rehabilitation of type Ⅱ hinge fractures. 
Methods The MOWHTO finite element models A and B, representing intact hinges and Takeuchi Ⅱ hinge fractures, were established using bone data from CT scans of the human lower extremities and incorporating TomoFix plates and screws. On the basis of model B, AFS was supplemented to construct model C. Different axial compressive loads were applied above the tibial plateau of the models, replicating states ranging from sitting to standing and walking. Additionally, torsional loads were applied to mimic rotational state. The maximum stress on the internal fixator, as well as the maximum displacement at the medial osteotomy site and the lateral hinge position under these conditions, was measured to evaluate the changes in mechanical stability at the osteotomy site. 
Results From the sitting to the standing state, compared with model A, the maximum stresses of the plates in models B and C increased by 178.3% and 95.9% respectively, the maximum displacement at the medial osteotomy site increased by 33.2% and 29.7% respectively, and the maximum displacement at the lateral hinge position increased by 51.0% and 43.7% respectively. The maximum stresses of the plate in the walking state increased by 113.1% and 91.9% respectively, and the maximum displacement at the medial osteotomy site increased by 17.2% and 13.8% respectively. The maximum displacement at the lateral hinge position increased by 389.4% and 385.1% respectively, and the maximum stresses of the plate under torsional load increased by 261.4% and 122.0% respectively. The maximum displacement at the medial osteotomy site increased by 362.6% and 242.1% respectively, and the maximum displacement at the lateral hinge position increased by 338.8% and 204.7% respectively. Compared with model A, the maximum stress of the plate in models B and C increased under various states, and the increase of model B was more obvious. Compared with the sitting to standing and walking states, the difference of the maximum stress increase of the plate between models B and C was the largest (139.4%) under the torsional load state. 
Conclusion This study demonstrates that type Ⅱ hinge fractures may result in a reduction of stability at the osteotomy site after MOWHTO, particularly during transitions from sitting to standing and twisting states. During the operation, the stability around the hinges needs to be strengthened, and corresponding actions should be performed under protective conditions after the operation. The supplemented AFS can enhance the stability of the osteotomy site and distribute the stress on the internal fixator. Theoretically, this approach could decrease the incidence of internal fixator failure, postoperative alignment deviation, and nonunion at the osteotomy site. Compared with the original internal fixation alone, it allows for earlier partial weight-bearing, which facilitates rapid recovery and minimizes complications. While AFS appears promising for the treatment of hinge fractures, further biomechanical investigations are warranted to confirm its efficacy. 


Key words:  , tibia, knee joint, osteotomy, finite element